Welcome to Innovation Cafe! I’m Gary Shuster, your friendly neighborhood inventor. Today, we’re tackling a subject that resonates deeply with many inventors: the emotional and practical challenges of letting go of an invention. Whether it is selling a patent, licensing technology, or simply deciding to shelve an idea, parting ways with something you’ve poured your creativity and energy into can feel overwhelming.
Let’s explore how techniques from therapy and emotional resilience can help you navigate the process of moving on, all while embracing the opportunities that come with letting go.
Why Letting Go is So Difficult for Inventors
Inventors often experience a unique attachment to their creations. Your invention isn’t just a product or a piece of intellectual property; it’s a part of you. You’ve nurtured it from concept to reality, celebrated its successes, and endured its challenges. Letting go—whether through selling, licensing, or moving on to the next project—can feel like saying goodbye to a piece of yourself.
This emotional connection is so powerful that it’s even backed by theories like the “personality theory of property.” Once we own something, it becomes more valuable to us than it might objectively be. For inventors, this sense of ownership is amplified by the hard work, immense investment of time and effort — effectively, the blood, sweat, and tears poured into creating something from nothing.
The Emotional Process of Letting Go
Letting go isn’t just about transferring ownership. It’s an emotional journey that involves fear, uncertainty, and sometimes even grief. However, like any challenging emotional experience, there are strategies to make the process more manageable.
1. Acceptance
The first step is acknowledging that letting go is a natural part of the invention process. Selling or licensing your patent isn’t the end of the road—it’s the beginning of a new chapter for both you and your invention. This transition allows your creation to thrive in the hands of those who can bring it to market, scale it, or integrate it into larger systems.
If you are considering selling a patent, know that the patent will naturally expire (normally 20 years after you file for it) — so you’re going to entirely lose control anyhow. Better to control how you lose control than to simply let it slide into the public domain. If you are considering copyrights, you don’t have the same concern — copyrights now last until seventy years after the author’s death (in the US, with exceptions, such as works made for hire that expire on a different calendar).
2. Cognitive Restructuring
This technique involves reframing how you view the situation. Instead of focusing on what you’re losing, focus on the opportunities ahead:
- For Your Invention: In the hands of a larger company or partner, your invention might achieve levels of success you could never accomplish alone.
- For Yourself: The sale of your invention can provide the resources, time, and freedom to focus on your next big idea.
By shifting your mindset from “I’m losing control” to “I’m opening doors,” you empower yourself to embrace the possibilities.
3. Mindfulness and Grounding
It’s easy to get lost in “what ifs.” What if the invention is implemented in a way that is not what I anticipated? What if it fails? What if I regret selling it? Mindfulness can help you focus on the present moment. Take a step back, breathe, and remind yourself of the facts:
- You created something remarkable.
- Someone values it enough to invest in it.
- This is an opportunity, not a loss.
- This is validation and a strong sign that you will be able to move on to another invention.
Setting Boundaries During Negotiations
Letting go doesn’t mean giving up all control. Just as healthy boundaries are critical in relationships, they’re essential in the inventor-patent dynamic.
- Define Non-Negotiables: What aspects of your invention must remain intact? For instance, if you’ve developed a technology with ethical implications, you might include licensing terms to prevent misuse. You should also consider what it is worth to you to be able to say “I sold patent 1,234,567 to GiantCo for $5 million”. Almost all license/assignment agreements will start out with a non-disclosure clause. Since purchasers almost always want in NDA to cover the deal, there is value to the NDA (I think the value is questionable, but if the buyer believes it has value you are unlikely to convince them otherwise). How much are you willing to reduce your payment in order to be get the buyer to leave out the NDA so you are able to talk about the deal? Think about it, because you will almost certainly run into the issue.
- Structure Deals Thoughtfully: Avoid agreements that rely solely on back-end payments. Ensure your compensation aligns with your goals, whether through upfront payments, royalties, or equity stakes.
- Consider Post-Deal Cooperation: You do not have to cooperate in helping the buyer implement your invention after the deal closes unless the contract requires it. I include a set amount of free consulting time in every deal I do, in hopes that the buyer will include me in thinking through how to implement the invention. Just do not expect them to include you, because sometimes they will not include you.
Setting clear boundaries ensures that even as you let go, you retain some influence over how your invention is used and its impact on the world.
Learning to Let Go and Move Forward
Selling an invention is a milestone, not a farewell. It’s a chance to celebrate your creativity and open up new opportunities for innovation. Remember:
- Letting go is necessary to free yourself for future projects.
- Selling or licensing your patent doesn’t erase your achievements—it builds on them.
- Every inventor faces this challenge. You’re not alone.
Final Thoughts: A Personal Perspective
As an inventor with over 250 patents, I understand how difficult it can be to part with an idea that’s deeply personal. I’ve been there. I’ve experienced the emotional tug-of-war, the pride in creation, and the sadness of letting go. But I’ve also seen how those moments of release paved the way for new and exciting opportunities.
Your creativity doesn’t end when you sell your patent. If anything, it marks the beginning of a new journey—one where you can reinvest in yourself and your ideas.
Share Your Experience
If you’ve navigated the process of letting go of an invention, I’d love to hear your story. Leave a comment below to share your experiences, tips, or questions.
Thank you for joining me at Innovation Cafe. Remember: Creativity is a gift we all share, and every end is the beginning of something new.
Keep innovating, and I’ll see you next time!
Pingback: The High Velocity Innovation Challenge: Choosing Which Inventions to Pursue