One of the most crucial facts about U.S. utility patents is that they expire 20 years from their filing date. This can greatly influence whether you pursue certain long-term inventions—and how you approach commercializing them. In the accompanying video, Gary Shuster explains how an early invention of his finally caught on in the marketplace just as his patent expired.
1. Understanding the 20-Year Span
- Filing Date Trigger
U.S. utility patents last 20 years from the date you first file (not counting the time you were pending with a provisional application). This term can be slightly adjusted with patent term extensions, but 20 years is the typical baseline. - Why It Matters
Once your patent expires, anyone can use your invention without licensing fees. If you’re developing technology that won’t see widespread adoption until well after that window closes, you might miss out on full commercial benefits.
2. The Perils of Future-Focused Inventions
- Delayed Market Adoption
Some products or technologies may take years—or even decades—to become viable in the marketplace. If your patent protections expire first, you may lose exclusivity just as the demand takes off. - Strategic Planning
Inventors should weigh the potential market timeline. If commercialization is likely to happen far in the future, consider whether the cost of patent pursuit is worth it. You could also try to hold onto the invention as a trade secret (if it is the kind of thing that is amenable to that) or delaying your patent application filing (in a first to file system, that’s super risky).
3. A Real-World Example: The Lockbox Invention
- The Problem
My laptop delivery was stolen off my porch, prompting me to invent a lockbox system with one-time-use codes—years before this was common. - Ahead of Its Time
Lockers from Amazon and other delivery services now use similar systems, but this widespread adoption took hold only after my patent expired. I haven’t done any kind of infringement analysis, so I’m not saying that their use would have been infringing even if the patent had not expired. The technology is pretty close though. - The Takeaway
Even a great idea can be too early. By the time market conditions catch up, your patent may no longer grant exclusive rights.
4. What Happens Post-Expiration?
- Open to the Public
Once a patent expires, anyone can make, use, or sell the invention without restriction. This fosters competition, potentially expanding the technology’s reach—but without ongoing royalties to the original patent holder. - Legacy and Influence
While no longer profitable as a protected IP asset, expired patents can still cement your status as a forward-thinking innovator.
5. Balancing Innovation and Timing
- Market Research
Evaluate the likely timeline for your invention’s adoption. - Filing Strategies
Consider whether a provisional patent or other strategies align with your product’s expected launch. - Continuous Improvements
You can file new applications for iterative innovations to refresh your patent protection if the core technology is evolving.
Want More Details?
Check out the accompanying Innovation Cafe video to hear Gary Shuster recount how his locker idea found success—two decades after he first patented it.
Pingback: How to Patent an Idea (the Right Way)